Ford 5.4L vs 4.6L vs 5.0L Engine: Which Is The Best?

Most people love the power, raw strength and thumping feel that they get from Ford cars, trucks, and SUVs. The 5.4L Triton, 4.6L V8, and 5.0L Coyote are three Ford engines that offer an almost unmatched driving experience.

The 4.6L engine is a naturally aspirated 8-cylinder machine. It was the foremost product in the Ford Modular engine family.

The 5.4L and 5.0L are beasts, thanks to their towing capability, torque, and power rating. We will examine the highlights of each engine and recommend the best option for you.

Ford 5.4L vs 4.6L vs 5.0L Engine: Comparison Chart

This table contains the main features of the 5.4L, 4.6L, and 5.0L. It provides an insight into the specifications, advantages, and potential problems of each engine

 5.4L4.6L5.0L
Firing order1-3-7-2-6-5-4-81-3-7-2-6-5-4-81-5-4-2-6-3-7-8 (VIN “N”)
1-3-7-2-6-5-4-8 (VIN “P)
Longevity300,000 miles300,000 miles300,000 miles
Towing capacity9,600lbs6,400lbs9,300lbs
Reliability/Common problems Blowing spark plugs
Development of Carbon deposits around the cylinder head.
Difficulty in removing the spark plug leakage of coolant and fluids, prone to cracking missing threads on the spark plugsStress, wear and tear of engine components like belts, hoses, and gaskets.
Torque350 lb-ft (standard, entry-level model)
450 lb-ft (Supercharged variant)
320 lb-ft @ 4000rpm400 lb-ft
Horsepower260HP (standard model)
380HP @ 4750 rpm (Supercharged variant)
292HP @ 5700rpm395HP

Based on the features given in the table above, we will now examine each engine in full detail.

Ford 5.4L vs 4.6L vs 5.0L Engine: Comparison Details

Horsepower And Torque

Winner: 5.0L Coyote

The basic version of the 5.4L Triton engine is capable of producing a torque of 350 lb-ft and 260hp. It produces a better throttle response compared to the 4.6L and 5.0L. 

With the aid of supercharging and other accessories, it should be able to deliver 450 lb-ft and 380hp at 4750rpm. The 4.6L V8 can give out 292 hp at 5700rm and 320lbft at 4000rpm.

Of these three Ford machines, the 5.0 Coyote offers the best balance, low-end torque, and speed. It is capable of delivering 400 lb-ft and 395 hp at 4250rpm.

Towing capacity

Winner: 5.4L engine

The 5.4L, 4.6L, and 5.0L engines have approximately the same longevity. It is a bit difficult to single out the best in this category. The three engines should be able to go up to 300,000 miles.

The life expectancy for any engine depends on its usage and how well you maintain it. If you use your truck to carry heavy loads regularly, it won’t last long compared to a vehicle used for conventional commuting.

If you adhere to a serious and consistent maintenance schedule, these three engines will last long. Replace all internal fluids and air filters regularly. In addition, monitor your cooling system and always check for any leaks.

Longevity

Winner: A tie between the three engines.

The 5.4L, 4.6L, and 5.0L engines have approximately the same longevity. It is a bit difficult to single out the best in this category. The three engines should be able to go up to 300,000 miles.

The life expectancy for any engine depends on its usage and how well you maintain it. If you use your truck to carry heavy loads regularly, it won’t last long compared to a vehicle used for conventional commuting.

If you adhere to a serious and consistent maintenance schedule, these three engines will last long. Replace all internal fluids and air filters regularly. Monitor your cooling system and always check for any leaks.

Firing order

The firing order for the Ford 4.6L and 5.4L engines is 1-3-7-2-6-5-4-8. The 5.0L engine has two variations with regard to the firing sequence. 

They are the VIN (Vehicle Identification Number) “P” type and the VIN “N” type. The firing pattern of the 5.0L VIN “N” engine is 1-5-4-2-6-3-7-8 while that of the VIN “P” type is 1-3-7-2-6-5-4-8.

Reliability

Winner: 5.0L

A 5.4L engine is a solid machine. However, it could develop problems with the spark plugs and ignition coils, timing chain issues, and failure of the fuel pump power module. With proper maintenance and checkups with a technician, you should be able to reduce the occurrence of these issues.

The Ford 4.6L V8 engine was good enough to power many flagship Ford vehicles for over two decades. Through its years of production, Ford introduced a number of modifications to the 4.6L engine to address early flaws. 

Therefore, the reliability issues associated with it vary from one vehicle model to another. Some are stable while others are prone to some failures. 

The major problems with the 4.6L include overheating due to poorly designed intake manifold, bad engine oil pressure, and engine misfires due to underlying problems. As a result, the 4.6L engine performs a little bit above average in terms of reliability.

The 5.0 Coyote is the most reliable option among the three engines. Meanwhile, the major challenges you could experience include a metallic ticking sound when the engine crosses 100,000 miles and slow gear shifts (with an automatic transmission).

Benefits And Drawbacks

5.4L Engine

Pros

  • Large engine displacement and high power output.
  • Good for towing heavy objects.

Cons

  • Spark plug problems
  • Average fuel economy

4.6L Engine

Pros

  • Good fuel consumption rate
  • Cost-effective compared to the 5.4L and 5.0L.

Cons

  • Produces less torque at low rpm
  • Low displacement and power due to weak stock rods.

5.0L Engine

Pros

  • Large engine displacement and high power output

Cons

  • More frequent maintenance is needed.

Which Car Models Have These Engines?

Many Flagship Ford vehicles have used the 4.6L, 5.0L, and 5.4L engines. The models and duration of use are given below.

5.4L Triton engine

  • Ford Falcon (2002-2010)
  • Ford E-Series (1997-2017)
  • Ford Expedition (1997-2014)
  • Ford Mustang (2000-2012)
  • Ford GT (2004-2006)
  • Ford F-150 (1997-2010)

5.0L Coyote engine

  • Ford F-150 (2011 – present)
  •  Ford Mustang ()2011-present)

4.6L Engine

4-valve 4.6L engine

  • Ford Mustang SVT Cobra (1996-2004)
  • Ford Mustang Mach 1 (2003-2004)

3-valve 4.6L engine

  • Ford Mustang GT (2005-2010)
  • Ford Explorer (2006-2010)
  • Ford F-150 (2008-2010)
  • Ford Mustang Bullitt (2008-2009)

2-valve 4.6L engine

  • Ford Mustang GT (1996-2004)
  • Ford Expedition (1997-2004)
  • Ford Thunderbird (1994-1997)
  • Ford E-Series (1997-2014)
  • Ford Explorer (2002-2005)
  • Ford Crown Victoria (1992-2012)
  • Ford F-150 (1997-2010)

Conclusion

The 5.0L is the best engine among the three Ford engines we have considered. It has the best performance, efficiency, least reliability issues, and decent longevity. Currently, this engine provides the best value to cost ratio.

However, the 4-valve 4.6L V8 and the 5.4L Triton are the next best advisable alternatives, depending on your budget. With a good maintenance culture and sleek driving technique, you are good to go!

Read more: 2.7L EcoBoost Vs. 3.5L EcoBoost Vs. 5.0L V8

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *